Welcome to the place of wisdom
The lotus does not reject the mud
I started crying before we even got off the bus. It was Constitution Day in Cambodia, a national holiday, and we knew that everyone had the day off. We had asked for only one thing: if possible, we wanted to meet an elderly Apsara dancer we had heard about, spend some time with her, and interview her. We knew something of her extraordinary story. We had been told that she was one of 124 Apsara dancers before the genocide of the 1970s and that, after the others were killed, she ultimately became the only survivor of that group. According to the story shared with us, she and two other young women had initially been spared and taken to a concentration camp, where they were tested and questioned, but in the end she was the one who survived. An entire living tradition had been reduced to a single human body carrying what she still remembered... Red Army wanted to destroy every spirituality that nation ever had.
That was why we wanted to meet her. We expected an interview, maybe a quiet conversation with an old woman who had somehow carried this knowledge through one of the darkest periods in Cambodia's history. We expected nothing else, especially on a national holiday. Instead, as our bus approached the school, I began to realize that something completely different had been prepared for us. The gates were open. The director had come. The teachers had come. ALL children were dressed and ready to dance. An altar had been prepared! Food was being made. People had come early to cook, organize the space, dress the children and prepare a welcome for a group of women they had never met. I sat in the bus staring through the window as the scale of what they had done slowly registered. We had simply asked to meet one woman. They had gathered a school... I was crying before my feet touched the ground.
What moved me so deeply was that Apsara dance was not being presented to us as entertainment. For the people who carry this tradition, and certainly in the way we experienced it there, dance is inseparable from prayer, devotion and the transmission of wisdom. This was something I understood immediately through my own practice of Sacred Dance. A sacred dance is not simply choreography performed beautifully for an audience. The body becomes part of the prayer. Movement becomes a way of entering relationship with something larger than yourself, a way of listening as much as expressing. You dance with God, with the sacred, with whatever language your tradition gives to that encounter, and sometimes understanding arrives through the body before the mind has words for it.
This is also why the survival of one dancer meant so much more to me than the survival of choreography. If the story we were being told was true in all its details, what had survived inside this woman was a living vocabulary: gestures, wisdom, God's word, discipline, embodied knowledge, memory and a way of relating to the sacred through movement. She had survived, and because she had survived, something could be taught again. Someone could learn from her, then teach another person, who could teach another. Decades later, we were sitting there watching children move their fingers into the same precise positions and train their bodies in an art that had come terrifyingly close to losing its human carriers.
And I loved seeing that this was not entirely confined to women. During our own Sacred Dance work in Cambodia, I had watched my teacher's husband dance with us. There were not many men participating, but seeing even a few of them enter this practice made me happy. Sacred Dance is often associated with the feminine, especially in the way I have encountered and practiced it, but prayer does not belong to one sex. Once someone has actually experienced what can happen when movement stops being performance and becomes prayer, the value of the practice becomes much easier to understand. Standing at that school, watching an ancient form being carried forward by another generation, I felt that connection very strongly. We had traveled there from completely different cultures, speaking different languages and practicing different forms, yet we recognized something in one another: a dance can be much more than a dance. It can be a way human beings remember what they consider sacred.
There is something about hospitality that becomes almost unbearable when you begin to see the work hidden inside it. We had come thinking that we were going to see them, to learn about their tradition, to watch their dance, but very quickly I realized that they had also been waiting to see us! We were told that foreign visitors did not normally come to them with this kind of interest and reverence for the tradition, so our arrival was an event for them as well. That changed something for me immediately. We were no longer consumers of another beautiful cultural experience. There were people on both sides of this encounter who were genuinely curious about one another. They wanted to show us what they had preserved, and we wanted to receive it.
Then a ninety-seven-year-old woman was waiting for us with her daughter and granddaughter, the one who inherited this tradition and opened up a school. Standing there that morning, I was struck by something larger than anything I've ever saw: three generations of women were standing in front of me, and suddenly the phrase preserving a tradition stopped being abstract. A tradition survives because somebody survives. Someone remembers the position of a hand. Someone remembers how the foot turns, what the gesture means, how one movement follows another. How to "listen" to God. She teaches it to another body, and that body carries it long enough to teach another. Knowledge moves through human beings this way, sometimes across centuries, but only because individual people refuse to let it disappear.
I looked at this tiny old woman and went to the floor to kiss her feet... We all kneeled in front of her thanking her for her courage, for her willingness to walk her truth, even though it almost costed her life. She only said - I couldn't do it any other way. We all cried that day. Only the day before, inside Angkor Wat, I had stood before a monk giving blessings and realized that I could not force my injured knee into the expected ritual posture simply to demonstrate reverence correctly. My wound was still open, kneeling hurt terribly, and I had understood something there about the decorative side of spirituality, about the temptation to make the outside of devotion look right even when the gesture itself has become disconnected from what is actually happening inside. Here nobody asked me to kneel. Nobody instructed me how to show respect. I saw this woman, and my body went down... I bowed at her feet and kissed them. The difference was immediate and very clear to me. I had not discovered that ritual was meaningless. I had discovered that the form itself cannot manufacture the feeling. A performed gesture begins with the form and hopes that meaning will follow... a genuine gesture begins somewhere much deeper, and sometimes the body has already moved before the mind has decided what the appropriate gesture should be. My wound did not open much. just a bit... it didn't hurt either...
We cried together. The women around me cried. She cried. And yes, I sniffed her too. I had to to breathe that woman inside me! She smelled wonderful! There was something almost unbearable about looking at a human being who had lived ninety-seven years in a country that had survived so much and seeing that what she carried had not disappeared. Yet the morning did not remain solemn for long, and I am glad it didn't. Soon the children began showing us how they trained every day, demonstrating the positions of their hands, fingers, arms and bodies that eventually become the extraordinary visual language of Apsara dance. Then we were invited to choose a child who would work with us individually and show us the exercises. There was one boy I had already noticed from the beginning. I kept looking at him and thinking: What a lovely boy. He doesn't even look Khmer. So when we were told to choose, I immediately thought: Well, obviously, that's my boy, and practically ran over to him. I sat down between him and a wonderful little girl, and the two of them began teaching me.
I loved the reversal of that scene. I had arrived in Cambodia as a Master of Sacred Dance. I teach, facilitate, work with bodies and know how to hold practices, and now I was sitting on the floor while two children corrected me and showed me what to do with my hands and my feet. There is something wonderfully healthy about being returned to beginnerhood, especially when you have become accustomed to being the person who knows. Later I discovered that the boy was French!!! His mother was standing nearby filming him and speaking French, and I had to laugh. Of course! Apparently my unconscious still has a type. I didn't need to make a cosmic sign out of it. It was simply another funny moment in a journey that had repeatedly shown me how quickly I recognize, prefer and judge before I consciously know why.
We danced with the children, learned from them, watched them demonstrate what they knew, hugged them and spent time with their teachers. The longer I stayed there, the less the word tradition felt like something ancient and frozen in history. Tradition was happening directly in front of me. It was the ninety-seven-year-old woman's body, her daughter's body, her granddaughter's body, a child's fingers being corrected by a teacher, and then my own foreign hands awkwardly trying to reproduce the same position. Knowledge was moving from one nervous system into another. Something that could have disappeared was still alive because human beings continued to embody it...
Before leaving, I wanted something physical to carry home from that encounter. Normally I am not particularly interested in souvenirs simply because I have visited a place. I don't need an object to prove that I have been somewhere. Cambodia was different. Here I kept wanting objects connected with very specific experiences, things that would carry a story rather than merely the name of a country. We learned about special bracelets associated with the Apsara dancers, made for them by a particular craftsman, and I immediately wanted them for the women in my own family. I wanted one for my mother, my sister, my daughters and myself. We ordered so many that people were apparently searching around the city to find enough for us. I loved the symmetry without needing to make too much of it. I had just been standing before several generations of Cambodian women through whom something had been carried forward, and I was leaving with small objects for several generations of my own women. I did not know what those bracelets would eventually mean to each of them. I knew why I wanted to bring them home. And now every single one of them accepted their gifts with tears in their eyes... I know they will ALWAYS cherish this women and these bracelets. They DO understand the cost of them.
And then Cambodia completely changed the mood. After days of blood, rain, temples, shaking, prayer, karma, death, strange coincidences and questions about the architecture of the universe, apparently I had done enough spiritual development for one week. Cambodia put me in a boat and gave me flowers... in the form of a wedding bouquette.
The lotus farm was pure pleasure, and I don't need a more sophisticated word for it. I loved everything! We learned about the lotus as a plant and as a symbol, about the extraordinary way it grows from mud and rises through the water until the flower opens above the surface clean and beautiful. The myth says it all - in order to become a wonderful flower like this out of the slums, one must have a pure heart... and the road to the farm looked exactly like this - slums... I have never seen such a poverty in my life... Just Google out of curiosity "Siem Reap Lotus Farm slums"... You drive through THAT before you see the beauty!
We smelled these flowers, touched them, learned how different parts of them are used and watched how incredibly fine fibers can be pulled from lotus stems and worked into pure silk! One square meter of this fabric costs $400. Apparently the richest fashion agencies are the customers... These people who work on these farms and live nearby prepared an entire meal for us from lotus, and I tasted things I had never eaten before. I bought lotus teas, oils, soaps and other little things to take home... After several days of encountering Cambodia through intensity, my body suddenly encountered it through fragrance, taste, texture, contrast and beauty, and I allowed myself to enjoy all of it without asking what lesson I was supposed to extract.
Then we went onto the water, and one of the Cambodian men took us out in a small boat. Somewhere along the way he began making things for me from the flowers. He made me a beautiful lotus headpiece and then an enormous bouquet that looked almost like a wedding bouquet. He seemed genuinely delighted by my delight, arranging flowers for me, handing them to me, trying to make everything beautiful and clearly enjoying the fact that I was enjoying it. I sat there surrounded by lotuses with this ridiculous magnificent crown on my head and a bouquet in my arms, feeling like some combination of a bride, a princess and a queen. I felt cared for. I felt beautiful. I felt spoiled in the sweetest possible way, and I let myself receive it.
That simplicity mattered to me more than I understood at first. Only a few days earlier, on the motorcycle ride to Kru, I had been evaluating the man assigned to carry me before we had even begun. He wasn't my type, he didn't look the way I thought the man carrying me should look, and I had immediately begun supervising how he drove. Here was another Cambodian man, also completely outside the usual categories through which I evaluate attraction, and I didn't need anything from the interaction beyond what was actually happening. I didn't need to know what his attention meant, whether he found me attractive, whether he was my type, what psychological pattern was being activated or what might happen next. Nothing needed to happen next. A man on a lotus farm wanted to make a woman in his boat happy, and the woman was happy. That was enough.
Only the day before, inside Angkor Wat, I had believed I was choosing the Path of Pleasure and later discovered that I had actually walked the Path of the Master. Now nobody was asking me to choose between anything. Pleasure had simply arrived in the form of flowers, food, fragrance, water, attention and a boat moving slowly through a lotus field. The irony was almost too perfect. I had spent so much of my life making growth serious, turning knowledge into achievement and achievement into another measure of worth, and here I was learning something while doing almost nothing except enjoying myself. The distinction between the Path of the Master and the Path of Pleasure was becoming less convincing with every day I spent in Cambodia.
The photographs from the lotus farm will be beautiful. A woman in a boat, surrounded by flowers, wearing a lotus crown and holding an enormous bouquet against a field of water and green leaves. It is exactly the kind of image we travel halfway around the world to bring home. But there is something outside that photograph, and by then I could no longer avoid seeing it. To reach the beautiful lotus field, we passed through places where people lived with very little by the standards I was accustomed to. There were extremely simple homes, flooded areas, damaged roads, children running through puddles and living conditions that, when I first arrived in Southeast Asia, my mind would have immediately categorized as dirty, poor, uncomfortable, dangerous and wrong. The people caring for this beautiful place lived there. The man making my lotus bouquet came from that world. The people who prepared our extraordinary food lived in conditions I would never have voluntarily chosen for myself, and yet they gave us their time, knowledge, food, flowers, attention and the very visible pleasure of making our experience beautiful. They gave us their hearts and shared their whole world! I remember looking at them and thinking something that would have sounded contradictory to me only a week earlier: these people are poor, but they are luxurious people. I don't mean that poverty makes anyone noble, or that having less somehow makes a person spiritually richer. I mean luxurious in an entirely different sense. There was an abundance in the way they received us, in their generosity, their tenderness, their willingness to share what they knew, what they grew, what they cooked, and what they had. I had arrived with a very Western understanding of abundance, one measured largely by what surrounds a person. Cambodia was showing me another kind, measured by what can move through a person toward someone else.
I do not want to romanticize poverty simply because witnessing it taught me something. A leaking roof is still a leaking roof. A flooded road is still a flooded road. People deserve sanitation, safety, healthcare, education, opportunity and comfort. Generosity does not make deprivation beautiful, and there is something deeply self-serving in the Western fantasy that people who have very little materially must somehow possess a spiritual richness that compensates for what they lack. I don't know what these people wanted for their own lives or what hardships they carried when tourists were not sitting in their boats. What shocked me was something more uncomfortable about myself: their material circumstances had told me absolutely nothing reliable about the quality of the human beings standing in front of me, yet when I first arrived in this part of the world, my mind had behaved as if they did.
I understood this even more clearly when I returned to Vietnam. I had passed through Vietnam on my way into Cambodia, and I remembered my reactions very well. Things felt dirty. Smells bothered me. Food looked unfamiliar and often unappealing. The disorder around me made my clean-freak nervous system immediately begin categorizing the environment. Then I came back through Vietnam after Cambodia and found myself in essentially the same world, yet suddenly everything seemed different. Food smelled wonderful. The streets felt alive. The same kinds of smells that had irritated me before no longer produced the same reaction. People looked different to me because I was looking differently. Vietnam had not had time to transform itself for my return. I had changed.
And what I saw in that contrast was my own ignorance. I don't use that word as self-punishment. I use it because I saw how quickly personal perception can disguise itself as objective truth. This smells bad to me had quietly become this smells bad. This food is unfamiliar to me had become this food is bad. These conditions are uncomfortable for the body I have spent fifty-one years living in had become this place is dirty. Somewhere in that process the words for me disappeared, and once they disappeared, my nervous system became an authority on reality. I was no longer describing my response to the world. I was describing the world as if my response had revealed what it actually was. Again, having filters is healthy. A certain degree of distrust can protect us when something genuinely feels wrong. The problem begins when that filter stays permanently switched on, protecting us not only from danger, but also from experiences that might be completely safe, pleasant, and worth receiving.
Later, while showering, I kept thinking about the lotus. We love the symbolism of this flower. We photograph it, perfume ourselves with it, drink lotus tea, eat lotus food, make oils and soaps from it and create extraordinary fabric from fibers hidden inside its stems. We admire the image of something so clean and beautiful rising from mud, and it easily becomes another elegant spiritual metaphor about purity overcoming darkness. But after that day I could no longer separate the flower from the conditions that produced it so neatly. The lotus does not grow in the photograph. It grows in mud. To reach the beautiful field where I sat dressed like a lotus princess, I had to travel through the places where the people tending that beauty actually lived. The flooded roads, simple houses, children in puddles and muddy water were not unfortunate scenery that needed to be cropped out before the real beauty began. They belonged to the same landscape.
By then I had also spent a week being much dirtier than my normal self prefers to be. I had been wet constantly, sweated through my clothes, rolled in red Cambodian earth until it was in my hair and under my nails, walked into toilets that were essentially holes in the floor and stood in liquid I genuinely did not want to identify. My hair was frequently a disaster. Makeup stopped mattering. Sometimes I barely knew where my bag was, where my phone was or what I looked like. At home I am absolutely capable of being a clean freak. I like order. I like things washed, organized and where they belong. None of that suddenly became wrong in Cambodia, and I have no intention of returning home, installing a hole in the floor and calling it enlightenment. What changed was that I experienced another part of myself, one who could be wet, sweaty, dirty, uncomfortable (to my mind) and completely immersed in life without constantly stepping outside herself to monitor how she appeared. I discovered another side of me...
That may have been one of the quietest freedoms Cambodia gave me. I did not become less valuable because I smelled like a human body. I did not become less feminine because there was mud under my nails. I did not become less beautiful because my hair was wet and dirty. I did not disappear because the conditions around me failed to meet my preferences. At some point I simply stopped spending so much energy observing myself from the outside. There was less checking of how I looked, what someone thought of me, whether I was behaving correctly, whether I had everything under control, whether I was sufficiently beautiful, prepared, spiritual or impressive. For stretches of time I was simply inside my body and inside my life.
The lotus began to mean something very different to me because of this. Its beauty does not require us to deny the mud. We are the ones who want to separate them because we prefer the flower. We want the photograph of the lotus field without necessarily wanting to see the flooded road leading to it. We want the handmade textile without thinking about the hands pulling almost invisible fibers from stem after stem (and she makes $4/day!). We want the ancient dance without always asking who survived long enough to remember it. We want the perfect gesture of the Apsara without seeing the child spending years training her fingers into positions that initially hurt. We want beauty after it has been cleaned, framed and presented to us, while so much of what makes that beauty possible remains outside the frame.
That morning, looking at a ninety-seven-year-old woman, I had understood that beauty survives because somebody carries it. A dance survives inside bodies. Knowledge survives because one person teaches another. A child becomes a teacher, and one day another child learns from her. A bracelet continues to exist because somebody still knows how to make it. The lotus tradition continues because people still grow the plants, harvest them, pull fibers from their stems, cook them, prepare teas and oils, and take strangers onto the water to show them why this flower matters. Even my beautiful afternoon in the boat existed because a whole network of people had done work I could easily fail to see while admiring the finished experience.
And people survive too, sometimes in circumstances I would find extremely difficult, without becoming reducible to those circumstances. They raise children, laugh, flirt, cook, work, make things, teach, welcome strangers and create beauty. A Cambodian man from a very different life than mine can take a woman from Minnesota onto a lotus field, decide that what she clearly needs is an enormous flower crown and a wedding bouquet, and give her an afternoon of almost ridiculous happiness. A ninety-seven-year-old woman can carry movements through a history that tried to erase them. Children can become teachers to an adult who arrived believing she was already a master. People who have materially less than I do can give me something I did not know how to buy.
I arrived in Southeast Asia noticing so much of what was missing. By the end, I was overwhelmed by how much was there. That realization did not erase hardship or turn poverty into something sacred. It showed me how incomplete my first perception had been. Awareness can be uncomfortable precisely because it eventually forces us to notice how much of the world we think we are objectively observing is passing through our own preferences, fears, standards, disgust, expectations, history and ideas about what a good life is supposed to look like. Sometimes the external world genuinely changes. And sometimes we return to almost the same place a week later and discover that the person doing the looking is no longer quite the same.
That evening I kept returning to the lotus and to the fact that it never needed to reject the mud from which it grew. It did not have to declare itself superior to its conditions in order to become beautiful. The mud and the flower belonged to one living system. Maybe that was what Cambodia had been showing me in different forms all week. Perfect balance! I did not need to stop loving cleanliness, beauty, comfort, order or the life I had built in order to encounter another world. I did not need to pretend that everything I saw was beautiful, safe or desirable. I needed enough space inside myself to encounter what was unfamiliar before deciding what it was worth.
By the time I left the lotus farm, I had eaten the flower, smelled it, touched it, watched its fibers become silk, floated among it, worn it on my head and carried an enormous bouquet of it in my arms. But the part I carried away most deeply was the part nobody puts in the beautiful photograph. The lotus had never asked the mud to become something else before it agreed to grow there.
I was finally learning to see the mud without missing the flower, and the flower without pretending there was no mud.